AI-generated Barbie creations are everywhere, but are they all legal? As the technology gets more advanced, so do the legal risks. Copyright and trademark concerns are growing, and regulation needs to catch up with the pace of digital innovation.
Here, we take a closer look at the legal challenges this cultural phenomenon poses.
Intellectual Property Concerns
Mattel strictly protects Barbie through copyrights and trademarks. Using her image in AI-generated content, particularly for profit, could violate those rights. With AI in the mix, it’s harder to define who’s responsible for potential infringement.
Data Privacy Implications
Many AI tools ask users to upload personal photos to create avatars, which raises serious concerns under data protection laws like the GDPR. This is especially true when biometric data is collected and processed without explicit consent.
Regulatory Developments
As generative AI grows more powerful, regulators struggle to keep pace. The EU is pushing forward with its Artificial Intelligence Act to ensure AI operates transparently and responsibly. Meanwhile, the UK is exploring how best to regulate AI where it overlaps with intellectual property and data privacy. However, with AI-generated Barbie avatars and music covers flooding the market, the law is still trying to catch up.
Copyright and AI: Government Consultation
The UK government is looking to change copyright laws to allow AI to mine text and data by default, unless creators object. While this supports AI development, it’s sparked backlash from many artists, writers, screenwriters and musicians, including high-profile names like Sir Elton John and Dua Lipa, who warn it could encourage copyright violations and devalue creative work.
Proposed Legislation and Pushback
Two major bills are currently being debated:
- The Data (Use and Access) Bill would require AI developers to be transparent about where their training data comes from, including any copyrighted materials. While the House of Lords has backed these transparency rules, the House of Commons has been hesitant, raising concerns about the potential economic impact.
- The Artificial Intelligence (Regulation) Bill, reintroduced in March 2025, aims to create an independent AI Authority. This body would oversee AI practices to ensure fair data use and respect for intellectual property rights. It would also set clearer rules around informed consent and transparency when AI systems are trained using content created by third parties.
Creative Industry Protest
The UK’s creative community is sounding the alarm. On February 25 2025, over 1,000 artists teamed up to release Is This What We Want?, a silent protest album calling out the risks AI poses to original art. The album features recordings of quiet, empty studios and stages, showing what could happen to musicians if the government’s plans go through.
It’s a clear message: without proper laws, generative AI could seriously devalue human creativity.
Collective Licensing on the Horizon
Taking a positive step, the Copyright Licensing Agency (CLA), the Authors’ Licensing and Collecting Society (ALCS), and the Publishers’ Licensing Services (PLS), plan to launch a collective licensing scheme in summer 2025.
The goal is fair payment for creators and greater transparency from AI companies about the data behind the content they generate.
Representatives from both the creative and technology sectors are set to meet in mid-2025 to negotiate legal agreements that fairly protect everyone’s interests, and we have yet to see the outcome.
What Can Small Businesses Do Now?
Moving forward, and while AI-related laws in the UK are still under discussion, small businesses can take simple and effective steps to stay compliant and
manage legal risks when using AI tools.
Actionable Steps:
Know how your AI tools work
Understand where the AI-generated data comes from and how it’s used. If the tool doesn’t clearly state its training sources, using the output in your business could carry legal risks.
Check your content for IP risks
AI can accidentally create content that looks like something owned by someone else, like a famous logo, song, or character. Using it without permission, especially for business, can put you at legal risk. Make sure you have the right licences before using anything that could be considered protected material.
Update your contracts and policies
If your services involve AI, whether it’s copywriting, social media, design, or similar, make sure:
- Your contracts and policies clearly explain how AI will be used
- Who owns the AI-generated content
- and specify any risks or limitations you’re disclaiming
Keeping your agreements up to date helps protect your business and ensures clients understand what to expect.
Be transparent with clients
Whether you use AI-generated text, images, or other media to support your services, let your clients know. Transparency not only builds trust but also helps you stay prepared for future regulations around AI use.
Stay informed
Last, but not least, it’s crucial to keep yourself informed. The rules around AI are changing fast, so it’s best to regularly review updates from expert sources and join relevant professional communities or newsletters. Proactive knowledge helps you stay ahead of potential risks and opportunities.
Conclusion
As generative AI becomes more powerful and easier to use, small businesses need to make sure they’re using it legally and ethically. With new UK regulations on the horizon, getting ahead now will save you headaches down the line.
Need help updating your contracts or AI disclaimers?
Get in touch for a contract review tailored to your business. We’ll help you stay protected as the law (and tech) evolves.